A free Carl-bot alternative with levels included
The short version: Carl-bot keeps levels, sticky messages and temp channels for its premium. Gildi runs all three on the free plan, next to role menus, moderation, logs and tickets.
Checked against Carl-bot’s own pages on 12 November 2026. Both bots change often. If something here is out of date, tell us and we’ll fix it.
Gildi vs Carl-bot, feature by feature
Gildi’s column comes straight from the limits the bot enforces. “Not on their site” means Carl-bot’s own pages don’t mention it.
| Feature | Gildi | Carl-bot |
|---|---|---|
| Levels | ||
| Leveling and rank cards | Yes, free | Premium only |
| Role rewards per level | 10 on Free, 50 on Plus, Unlimited on Pro | Premium only |
| Import XP from MEE6 | Built in, free | Yes, with /level mee6import |
| Community | ||
| Sticky messages | 3 on Free, 25 on Plus, Unlimited on Pro | Premium only |
| Temporary voice channels | 1 on Free, 5 on Plus, Unlimited on Pro | Premium only |
| Role menus | 5 on Free, 25 on Plus, Unlimited on Pro | Up to 250 reaction-role pairs |
| Suggestions | 1 on Free, 5 on Plus, Unlimited on Pro | Yes, with a decision log |
| Starboard | 1 on Free, 3 on Plus, Unlimited on Pro | Yes |
| Moderation and logs | ||
| Automod filters | Yes, free | Yes, with per-rule punishments |
| Anti-raid | Yes, free | Not on their site |
| Log history | 3 days on Free, 30 days on Plus, 90 days on Pro | Yes, split across channels |
| Ban appeals with a web form | 3 questions, 1 reviewer decides on Free, 10 questions, 2 to 5 reviewers must agree on Plus, 10 questions, 2 to 5 reviewers must agree on Pro | Not on their site |
| Commands and price | ||
| Custom commands | 10 on Free, 50 on Plus, Unlimited on Pro | Yes, written in TagScript |
| Tickets | 3 on Free, 10 on Plus, Unlimited on Pro | Not on their site |
| Your own bot picture | Nickname only on Free, Picture, banner, About me on Plus, Picture, banner, About me on Pro | Custom avatar and banner on premium |
Where Carl-bot is the better pick
We’d rather you pick the right bot than switch and regret it. Carl-bot wins on a few things, and they’re real:
- Its reaction roles go deep. Unique, verify, reversed, binding and temporary modes, with up to 250 pairs per server.
- Stream alerts and free-game alerts. Carl-bot posts Twitch and YouTube alerts and free games. Gildi has no social alerts yet.
- TagScript is powerful. If your team already writes TagScript, those commands won’t copy across to Gildi’s flows.
- Your mods probably know it. It has been around for years, so there are plenty of guides and people who know it.
Switching, without a bad week
You don’t have to remove anything to try Gildi. Run both for a few days. More on switching bots.
- Add Gildi alongside
Both bots can sit in the server. Start with what Carl-bot charges for: levels, sticky messages and temp voice.
- Rebuild role menus and commands
Set up your role menus with buttons, dropdowns or reactions, and rebuild custom commands as flows.
- Swap over
Move automod and logs last, check a week of logs side by side, then remove Carl-bot.
Questions
Is Gildi a free Carl-bot alternative?
Yes. Every Gildi module is on the free plan with no time limit, including the levels, sticky messages and temp voice that Carl-bot keeps for premium.
Can I bring my Carl-bot levels over?
Not directly. Gildi imports levels from MEE6 only. Carl-bot uses the same XP curve as MEE6, but there’s no import from Carl-bot itself yet.
Do my TagScript commands work in Gildi?
No. Gildi’s custom commands are flows you build on the dashboard. Most simple tags take a few minutes each to rebuild.
Can both bots run at once?
Yes. Just keep only one of each module on, such as automod or welcome messages, so members don’t get everything twice.
What does Gildi charge for?
Room, not modules. Plus and Pro raise limits such as flows, role menus and log history, and Pro runs Gildi under your own bot name.
What you’d use instead
Compared with other bots
Try Gildi next to Carl-bot
Add Gildi, set up the modules you use, and see how it feels for a week. Nothing to cancel if you change your mind.